Picking Shares is Mostly Luck

A new study from Vanguard gives more evidence for why the LADS method of investing works.

Just 10 companies out of 12,500 created 30% of the wealth in the US share market from 1990 to 2025. That’s 0.08% chance of picking a winner.

That’s the same odds as hitting black ten times in a row on a roulette table. Not very likely.

75% of companies failed to outperform the index. This is a reflection of the fact that the most a company can lose is 100% but the most it can gain is infinite.

The best performing company from 1926 to 2025 in the US share market return 442.1 million percent, or $4.42 million per dollar initially invested.

Why stock returns are inherently skewed: The roots of this positive skewness lie in a simple first principle of investing. For any individual stock, the maximum loss is limited to 100% of the capital invested, while the potential gain is theoretically unlimited. Over long horizons, this asymmetry compounds dramatically. We are often taught that “trees do not grow to the sky,” but in equity markets some do. The gains generated by a handful of extraordinary winners overwhelm the losses from a much larger number of disappointing investments. As a result, long-term equity returns are driven less by avoiding losers than by successfully identifying – and, crucially, continuing to hold the rare companies that compound value for decades.

This is yet more evidence to focus on what your can conto. Keep your investments low-cost, automated, diversified, and simple.